Skip to content
OnRubric

How to read a rubric before you start writing

9 min read · updated

To read a rubric, start with the criteria and their points, which tell you what is graded and how much each part counts. Then read each criterion across every level, including the lowest, and mark the words that change from one level to the next. Those words are the requirement. Turn the top level into a short list of things your draft must contain, and ask your instructor about anything the rubric leaves open.

What is a rubric?

A rubric is a scoring guide that lists what an assignment is graded on and describes what the work looks like at each level of quality. Susan Brookhart, who writes about assessment for teachers, defines it as “a coherent set of criteria for student work that describes levels of performance quality” in How to Create and Use Rubrics for Formative Assessment and Grading (ASCD). The criteria say what counts. The level descriptions say what each grade looks like on the page.

Reading a rubric means working out, from its own words, what your paper needs before you write it. Scoring a finished draft is a later step, covered in how to grade your own essay with a rubric. This guide is about the first read.

In a focus-group study, 14 undergraduates told Heidi Andrade and Ying Du that they used rubrics to plan assignments, check their work and make sense of feedback. Their comments also suggested that most of them did not read a rubric all the way through (Andrade & Du, 2005). It is a small study, and it rests on what students said about their own habits.

What are the parts of a rubric?

A rubric attached to a college assignment is often a grid. Four parts carry the information:

Part Where it usually is What it tells you
Criteria The left column, one per row What is graded, such as the thesis, evidence, organization or citations
Levels The column headings The quality scale, as labels (Exemplary to Beginning), numbers (4 to 1) or letter grades
Descriptors The cells What work at that level looks like for that criterion
Points Beside each criterion, or in each cell How much each criterion counts, and what each drop in level costs

The descriptors are the part most worth your time. Two papers can both have a thesis and land two levels apart, because the higher descriptor asks for something specific that one of them lacks. A criterion name like “Thesis and position” tells you the topic of the row. The descriptors tell you what to write.

What kind of rubric do you have?

The University of South Carolina’s Center for Teaching Excellence describes three types of rubric: holistic, analytic and single-point (Types of Rubrics). You read each one a little differently. The fourth row below is not on USC’s list, but some assignment sheets come with one.

Type What it looks like How to read it
Analytic A grid. Each criterion gets its own score, and criteria can carry different weights Row by row. Compare neighboring levels within each row and note the points
Holistic One description per level for the whole paper, and one overall score Read each level as a set of features that should appear together. Find the level your plan reaches, then read the one above it
Single-point One description per criterion at the proficient level, with space for comments Treat each description as the bar to clear. Ask what earns more, since the rubric may not say
Points checklist A list of requirements with points and no levels Treat each line as present or missing, and ask whether partial credit exists

The steps below assume an analytic rubric, the grid with a score per row. They work for the other types with the changes in the right-hand column.

How do you read a rubric, step by step?

  1. Put the rubric next to the assignment sheet. Use the rubric attached to this assignment, not a generic one or a version from another course. Some descriptors point outside the rubric. The evidence row in the example below asks for sources that meet “the assignment minimum”, and that number is on the assignment sheet. The UNC Writing Center’s handout on understanding assignments says to read the assignment carefully as soon as you receive it.
  2. List the criteria with their points. Write each criterion down with its points and its share of the total. A criterion worth 25 of 100 points carries a quarter of the grade. If the rubric shows no points, ask whether the criteria count equally before you decide where your time goes.
  3. Read each row across, all the way down to the lowest level. Finish one criterion before you start the next. The top column alone describes an ideal paper. The lower descriptors often name the specific mistakes that cost points, and that is the most useful thing to know before you write.
  4. Mark the words that change between neighboring levels. Put two adjacent descriptors side by side and underline what differs: a count (“at least one”, “one or two places”), a quantifier (“every”, “most”, “some”), a location (“the last one or two sentences of the introduction”) or a quality word (“arguable”, “credible”, “specific”). Those differences decide which level a paper gets. Claire Helakoski of the Walden Writing Center gives the same advice for a graded paper: read the description where you scored lower than you wanted, “then read the area in the next point category up” (Walden Writing Center blog, 2018).
  5. Turn the top level into a must-include list. For each criterion, write the features of the top descriptor as items your draft has to contain, with a location wherever the descriptor gives one. Use the list to check your outline. After you draft, each item becomes a question you can answer by pointing at a sentence.
  6. Circle the words you cannot test. “Appropriate”, “sufficient”, “effectively” and “sophisticated” do not say what to put on the page. Look them up in what common rubric phrases mean, check the assignment sheet, and ask about the ones that are still unclear. The UNC handout tells students to “ask the instructor about anything you do not understand.”
  7. Set the rubric aside while you draft, then come back to it. The Walden post suggests reviewing the rubric before the first draft to see which parts of the work matter most, then putting it aside to focus on the writing, and reading it again once you have a polished draft.

What does reading a real rubric row look like?

The example uses OnRubric’s argumentative essay rubric. It is written in our own words, not taken from a university, and has six criteria worth 100 points in total, each with four levels.

Step 2, the points. Evidence and support carries 25 points and Thesis and position carries 20, so 45 of the 100 points depend on the thesis and the evidence behind it. Counterargument, organization and writing mechanics carry 15 each, and APA 7 citations carry 10. The levels have points too. On the thesis row they are worth 20, 16, 12 and 6, so in this rubric even the lowest level earns something, and each step down costs at least 4 points.

Steps 3 and 4, one row across. Here is the thesis row as the rubric states it:

Level Points Descriptor
Exemplary 20 A single arguable thesis appears in the last one or two sentences of the introduction, names the position, and previews the main reasons. Every body paragraph can be traced back to that claim, and the conclusion restates it in different words without introducing new points.
Proficient 16 A clear thesis is present in the introduction and is arguable, but it either does not preview the reasons or is slightly broader than what the body actually argues. Most body paragraphs connect to it.
Developing 12 The thesis is a statement of fact or a topic announcement (‘This essay will discuss...’) rather than a claim someone could dispute, or it is buried in the middle of the essay. Some body paragraphs drift away from it.
Beginning 6 No identifiable thesis, or the essay argues more than one position and never settles on one.

Read neighboring levels in pairs and the requirements show up:

  • Beginning to Developing (6 more points). The essay needs one identifiable thesis and one position.
  • Developing to Proficient (4 more). The thesis has to be a claim someone could dispute. A fact or an announcement of the topic stays at Developing. It also has to sit in the introduction, and most body paragraphs have to connect to it.
  • Proficient to Exemplary (4 more). The thesis previews the main reasons and matches what the body argues. It sits in the last one or two sentences of the introduction. “Most” body paragraphs becomes “every” body paragraph, and the conclusion restates the thesis without adding new points.

Step 5, the must-include list. Before outlining, the thesis row becomes five items:

  • One thesis, in the last one or two sentences of the introduction
  • A position a reader could dispute
  • The main reasons, named in the thesis itself
  • Body paragraphs that each trace back to the thesis
  • A conclusion that restates the thesis in new words and adds no new point

The evidence row has a detail worth catching on the first read. Its Exemplary level asks for “one to three sentences” of explanation after every quotation or paraphrase, while Proficient allows “one or two places” where a quotation is dropped in without explanation. The number of sources is not in the rubric at all. It is whatever the assignment sets as its minimum. When you get to that row in a draft, check your essay evidence against the rubric claim by claim.

What should you ask your instructor about the rubric?

A question that quotes the rubric is easier to answer than “what do you want?” The UNC handout says instructors “would prefer to set you straight before you hand the paper in.” Adapt these to your rubric’s wording:

  • “The evidence row says sources must meet the assignment minimum. Is that the number on the assignment sheet, and which kinds of source count toward it?”
  • “The rubric has no points. Do all the criteria count the same?”
  • “One row asks for an appropriate tone. Is there a sample paper that shows what you mean?”
  • “This is a single-point rubric. What would put a paper above the standard on this criterion?”
  • “Is this the rubric you will grade with, or an example from another section?”

Ask early, while the answer can still change your outline.

What mistakes make a rubric harder to use?

  • Reading only the top column. You learn what an ideal paper looks like and nothing about what loses points.
  • Reading the criterion names and skipping the descriptors. “Organization and structure” could cover topic sentences, paragraph order, transitions or the conclusion. The descriptor says which of those this rubric looks for.
  • Giving every row the same attention. A 25-point row deserves more planning time than a 10-point row. When you revise later, prioritizing essay revisions with a rubric uses the weights the same way.
  • Reading it for the first time after the draft is finished. By then the structure is set, and a missing counterargument may need a new paragraph plus changes to the paragraphs around it.
  • Reading rubric words in their everyday sense. In a rubric, “critical” asks you to judge evidence, which can include saying a source is strong. “Analysis” asks what a finding means and how far to trust it.
  • Writing sentence by sentence to the rubric. Helakoski points out that how the parts of your work add up to a score is up to your instructor, and that you shouldn’t stress too much about the rubric while you write. Use it to plan and to check, and put it away in between.

Rubric reading checklist

Where does a rubric checker fit?

The first read is yours to do, since there is no draft to check yet. Once you have a full draft, OnRubric’s rubric checker takes the same rubric and the draft. You can paste the rubric from Canvas or Blackboard, photograph it, or pick one from the library. A pasted rubric should include each criterion with its points and level descriptions, the same parts this guide reads. For every criterion, OnRubric estimates a score range, quotes the sentences from your draft behind the estimate and names what is missing. From a photo, it lists the criteria and points it read, so you can compare them with the original before the check runs.

Compare its quotes with your must-include list. Where they disagree, reread the paragraph and the descriptor. The estimate is a prediction, not a grade, and your instructor decides. Before you upload a paper or a rubric to any AI tool, check your course’s rules, and ask if they do not say.

Before you start writing

Take the criterion with the most points. Put its top two descriptors side by side, underline what differs, and write those words at the top of your outline. Then do the same for the next row down the list.

Short answers

What do the columns on a rubric mean?

On most grid rubrics, each column is a level of quality, such as Exemplary, Proficient, Developing and Beginning, often with points. Each row is one criterion. The cell where a row meets a column describes what work at that level looks like for that criterion.

What is the difference between an analytic and a holistic rubric?

An analytic rubric scores each criterion separately, so you can see where points went. A holistic rubric gives one overall score, matched to a description of the whole paper at each level. Read each holistic level as a set of features that should appear together.

What is a single-point rubric?

A single-point rubric describes one level for each criterion, usually the proficient standard, and leaves space for the instructor’s comments. Treat that description as the bar your paper has to clear. If the rubric does not say what earns more, ask your instructor.

What if my rubric has no point values?

Look for weights in the assignment sheet and the syllabus. If neither gives them, ask your instructor whether every criterion counts the same. Planning around a weighting you guessed can send your time to the wrong parts of the paper.

Should I read the rubric before or after I write?

Both. Read it before you outline to see what is graded and how much each part counts. Read it again after a full draft, row by row, to check the paper against each level. Walden’s Writing Center suggests setting it aside while you draft.